skip navigation


Officially Speaking: Rule Ignorance

By Dec 27, 2018 | Officially Speaking 01/16/2019, 10:45pm EST


By Mark Lichtenfeld. Originally published at State of Hockey:


Western Regional Silver Sticks just left town and though the hockey was pretty much legitimate AA as advertised, OS was most surprised by the ignorance of basic USA Hockey rules displayed by several of the coaches. I mean, this is 16U and 18U AA, and at the very least, coaches should be expected to master some of the well-known playing regulations, no?

Rule misapprehension No. 1. Too Many Players on the Ice.

So the coach of a certain 16U team, replete with oversized USA Hockey National Championship patch donning the chest area of his jacket, gets all flustered when I called a too many players infraction on the opponent.

“What’s wrong?” I query.

“You waited 15 seconds to shut the play down,” he hollers.

“Yeah, that’s when the offending team gained possession,” I retort.

“That’s not the rule for a too many players penalty,” he insists. “You have to blow the whistle immediately.”


So let’s look at USA Hockey Rule 409.

Rule 409 | Calling of Penalties

(a) Should an infraction of the rules be committed by a player of the team in possession and control of the puck, the Referee shall immediately stop play and assess the penalty(s) to the offending player(s).

Now, it’s true that this rule refers to “player of the team,” but that is a problem with the rulebook verbiage. In fact, the rulebook that makes no exception to the team in possession rule when the infraction is too many players. Like any other “infraction of the rules” being assessed against a single team, play continues until the offending team obtains possession.

Rule ignorance No. 2. The simple USA Hockey Rule 409 scenario when a shorthanded team is being assessed a delayed penalty and the opponent scores a goal.

Rule 409(b). If the Referee signals an additional minor penalty(s) against a team that is already shorthanded (below the numerical strength of its opponent on the ice at the time of the goal) because of one or more minor or bench minor penalties, and a goal is scored by the non-offending team, the goal shall be allowed. The delayed penalty(s) shall be assessed and the first non-coincidental minor penalty already being served shall terminate automatically under Rule 402(c) (Minor Penalties).

OK, so try explaining this to a 16U AA coach who’s been plastered on the sofa watching too much idiot box and insists that the delayed penalty is waved off while the original offender stays in the box. So what if that’s the NHL rule? This is USA Hockey, right? And you’re supposed to be a AA coach competing in the Western Regional Silver Sticks. Watch out for this, you coaches, parents and impressionable players.

Rule insanity No. 3. Tell me, how does an 18U AA head coach not comprehend the USA Hockey high-sticking rule? You know, when a player plays the puck with a stick above the shoulder resulting in a stoppage and a faceoff in the offending team’s defensive end zone.

Let me repeat this one more time for you ignorant coaches. I say ignorant only because no one, coaches in particular, should ever call out a veteran official for an alleged rule error when that coach himself is ignorant of the very rule debated. In this case, the rule is the USA Hockey high-sticking Rule 621(c), and here is the applicable casebook scenario:

Situation 8: A player high sticks the puck which deflects to an opponent. The opponent makes no attempt to play the puck, hoping to get a faceoff in the offending team’s Defending Zone when the puck is first played by a member of the offending team. What should the Referee do?

The Referee should stop play and the ensuing faceoff shall take place at an end faceoff spot in the Defending Zone of the offending team. Rule Reference 621(c).

The non-offending team has no obligation to play the puck in this instance, because of the high stick infraction committed by the opposing team.

Got that, Mr. 18U AA coach? I stopped play because the opposing team wasn’t interested in playing the puck since they understood the rule.

In sum, and this is for you younger players in particular, as you proceed through college and life in general, never engage in debate with an opponent unless you are absolutely certain of your facts AND you are positively convinced your opponent is ignorant of his or her respective facts.

Because as the aforementioned scenarios illustrate, certain coaches have lost credibility with their young players, and credibility lost is immensely difficult to retrieve.


Read more Officially Speaking

Predators coach Dan Muse’s advice for 14U/16U players

By By Michael Rand from USA 01/16/2019, 10:45pm EST

As an up-and-coming coach, Dan Muse occupies an interesting space. At age 36, he’s already in his second season as a Nashville Predators assistant coach, but he also has enough recent experience at lower levels, including high school and college, that he can offer a unique perspective on player development.

As such, we tapped Muse’s expertise for some tips this month aimed at 14U and 16U players. Here are some of the key takeaways from our conversation.

Hockey sense is key

Muse says a key separator for top players as they approach higher levels of hockey is their sense and feel for the game.

“I’ve coached from a lot of different vantage points. In college, where I was in 16U rinks and unfortunately even 14U for recruiting, I was looking to see players who have good habits and understand the game – have game sense,” Muse said. “I think that’s something that’s developed over time.”

That means learning how to support the puck by moving into areas where you can be useful to a teammate in trouble while playing with speed and awareness, among other things.

“For younger players, the systems should be secondary. The first thing you should be looking to do every day is developing a skill set, habits and game sense,” Muse added. “It’s on coaches to put players in an environment to develop general concepts and developing habits. Those are going to be parts of your game that transfer from level to level, team to team, regardless of system.”

Those environments include small-area games and high-pressure situations with limited time and space, along with encouraging unstructured pickup hockey whenever possible.

Build habits and instincts

As players get bigger and faster, the amount of time a player has to make decisions decreases. By building good habits early, that transition is smoother. But it takes work, Muse says.

“The game is so fast that you have to do it instinctually. You can’t stop and press pause. You have to work on those habits,” he said. “That’s where I really like what USA Hockey is doing. They’re doing an amazing job with small-area games, creating an environment where they’re going to play in tight areas with a purpose in mind. That purpose, when there’s a plan for it, players have to think and react, and as a result, they’re building those habits and instincts that are going to become natural over time.

“For long-term success, you need to be in an environment to build habits that translate. Learning how to read and react and support pucks, defensively learning how to use the stick and close out space. USA Hockey has done a really good job of helping promote teaching those things,” Muse said. “We’re developing our players to get better in this league or take on new roles and play longer. For the younger levels, it’s different. What’s the priority? It should be to make each player better while growing within a team structure.”

Faster, faster, faster

If you think hockey is fast at 14U or 16U, just wait.

“The game is so fast. Plays happen so quickly. So for young players coming up, if you want to be working toward your full potential – and everyone wants to play at their highest level – it’s pushing yourself to play at that speed. I don’t see it slowing down, it’s only getting faster,” Muse said.

That might mean creating short-term discomfort by pushing yourself to try new things when it would be easier to rely on old habits to dominate.

“If you’re 14U, 16U, every practice you have a choice,” Muse said. “For some, maybe it comes easier. But if they want to play at a higher level, they need to push themselves now to be mastering things as fast as they can. If you don’t, and you get to those levels, you’re going to be a step behind.”

Success takes work

Muse has seen up close what goes into the daily preparation for an NHL player and can also reflect on how much work it took for players to get to that level.

“They make it look easy, but their habits and attention to detail are so strong that they’ve gotten to the point that it’s instinctive. That takes a long time and a lot of work, and that goes back to working those parts of their game at a young age,” he said. “You have a lot of players who were blessed with natural talent, but it was hard work for all these guys to get to this point. You see it in the daily habits, how they take care of themselves and their practice habits.”


To see more news items visit the CSYHA News Page